What is the "Best Rolex Submariner?"

When it comes to debate, watch enthusiasts do it best. We love to discuss which Rolex watch is the best, and an even more precise debate—“which Rolex Submariner is best”—often finds its way into online forums, Instagram posts, and watch meetup groups. For me, one particular model stands out above all the others.

Setting the Ground Rules

To determine “the best Rolex Submariner,” I’ve set some criteria.

1. Case Dimensions and Bracelet Feel: These are my first priorities.
2. Reliability and Serviceability: How robust and easy to maintain is the watch?
3. Connection to the Submariner Legacy: How does the model honor the past while shaping the future? Where does it rank on the iconic scale?
4. Personal Preferences: A mix of pros and cons that make this particular model stand out.

The Best Submariner: Rolex Submariner Date Ref. 16610LN (2007–2010)

To cut to the chase, my pick is the Rolex Submariner Date, Ref. 16610LN, produced from 2007 to 2010. The serial number for this model begins with “M,” so all Rolex Submariners from this period will have an “M” serial. Specifically, I believe the all-black dial and bezel version is the perfect choice. During this period, Rolex also produced a green bezel version with a Maxi-Dial and handset. While that’s a great watch, it doesn’t quite evoke the iconic vibe of the traditional LN model.

Dimensions and Bracelet

Here are the case dimensions for the watch:

• Case Thickness: 12.7 mm
• Lug-to-Lug: 47.6 mm
• Bezel Width: 40.0 mm
• Case Width at Its Widest: 39.37 mm
• Crystal Width: 29.85 mm

These dimensions have become the gold standard for watch case proportions. While earlier and later models made minor tweaks, none have truly improved on this design. On my wrist—and many others’—it looks and feels perfect.

The bracelet, while lacking the micro-adjustment system of the current Submariner, somehow feels superior. I love the simplicity of the stamped clasp, and the hollow center links make it incredibly lightweight. It’s easily the most comfortable bracelet I’ve ever worn.

Reliability and Serviceability

The Rolex Submariner 16610 is remarkably easy to repair and maintain. If the bezel pops off, you can reassemble it in two minutes with a YouTube tutorial. The 3135 movement is rock-solid, offering accuracy nearly on par with a quartz watch, even if you skip a servicing.

Made from high-quality 904L steel, the watch is highly resistant to damage and corrosion. Its sapphire crystal ensures it won’t scratch or crack easily, unlike earlier models. This watch is built like a tank—easy to repair, incredibly durable, and even more charming with a few scratches.

By contrast, newer models are impressive but harder to service, requiring specialized training. Older vintage models are less robust, and sourcing original parts can be prohibitively expensive. The 16610 strikes the perfect balance for a Rolex owner.

Relationship to Past and Current Models

The Rolex Submariner 16610 is like the cool older sibling connecting the past and present. Produced from 1988 to 2010, it retains the timeless charm of the Submariner while incorporating modern upgrades. Think vintage style with a contemporary twist: one of the first Submariners to replace acrylic crystals with sapphire—a game-changing improvement still unmatched by current models.

It also introduced the caliber 3135 movement, renowned for its precision and reliability. Interestingly, I’ve found the newer 3235 movement to be less accurate than the 3135 in my own watches.

The 16610 keeps the aluminum bezel insert, paying homage to its vintage roots before ceramic bezels took center stage. It also maintains a sleek, classic case shape, avoiding the bulkier aesthetic of today’s Submariners. For collectors, it’s the perfect blend of nostalgia and innovation.

Positives and Negatives of the 16610

Positives:

• Aluminum Bezel Insert: This is a standout feature for me. It’s timeless and elegant. While the ceramic bezels on newer models are beautiful, they smudge easily. I prefer the vintage charm of aluminum.
• Bracelet: The bracelet is both a positive and a quirk. While it lacks modern features like easy adjustments and can be challenging for those with small wrists (due to fixed links on the six o’clock side), once sized correctly, it’s the most comfortable bracelet Rolex has ever made. The lightweight feel and flawless fit are impressive for such a simple construction.

Iconic Dial Design

Lastly, the dial is just iconic. The thinner hands and markers are so clean and readable. It connects the new with the old models, and the lume is frankly mind-blowing for a 12–15-year-old watch.

Conclusion: Why the 16610 M-Series is the Best Rolex Submariner

In the endless debate of which Rolex Submariner reigns supreme, the Ref. 16610LN takes the crown for me. It’s the perfect blend of classic design, modern upgrades, and practical functionality. From its timeless dimensions and lightweight bracelet to its reliable, easy-to-service movement, this model hits all the right notes. It feels like a love letter to the Submariner’s heritage while confidently stepping into the future.

Sure, it’s not without its quirks—the stamped clasp and lack of micro-adjustment might not be for everyone—but these details add to its charm. The 16610LN isn’t just a watch; it’s a bridge between eras, embodying everything that makes the Submariner iconic. For collectors and enthusiasts, it’s the ultimate sweet spot: refined, robust, and undeniably cool.

Final, final note...if you own a Submariner or any other type of Rolex do not hesitate to check out our strap options! They are the perfect way to save your Rolex bracelet, enjoy a new look and customize your Rolex!